Early Times Report JAMMU, Nov 20: In a significant judgment concerning alleged fraudulent mutation of 60 kanals and 16 marlas of land in Kishtwar district, the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has quashed the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) chargesheet against the petitioners, holding that mere attestation of revenue mutations, without material establishing dishonest intention, illegal gratification or criminal conspiracy, cannot attract the provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Justice Sanjay Dhar, while allowing a petition filed by Pardeep Singh and others, observed that the criminal proceedings arising from the disputed land mutations amounted to an abuse of the process of law. The judgment, pronounced on November 19, 2026, relates to FIR No. 03/2014 registered by the then Vigilance Organisation Jammu, now ACB, under provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B of the Ranbir Penal Code. According to the prosecution, a complaint was lodged before the Vigilance Organisation on February 3, 2011, alleging that land measuring 60 kanals and 16 marlas under Khasra No. 2772/583 min in village Pouchal, Kishtwar, had been fraudulently mutated in favour of certain private individuals. The complaint alleged that the land had been reflected as government land in revenue records since 1971 and that the mutations were carried out to facilitate wrongful claims for compensation in connection with the Kishtwar-Chatroo-Sinthan road project. During preliminary verification, the investigating agency found that the land was recorded as Shamilat Deh land in which proprietary landholders of the village had proportionate shares. However, the agency alleged that certain revenue officials, acting in conspiracy with the beneficiaries, had manipulated the revenue records to confer exclusive rights over a portion of the land falling within the proposed road alignment. The investigation implicated several revenue officials, including the then Tehsildar Kishtwar, Girdawar and Patwaris, along with the private beneficiaries of the disputed mutations. During the hearing, Senior Advocate Abhinav Sharma, assisted by Advocates Abhirash Sharma and Asheesh Singh Kotwal, appeared for the petitioners. For the respondents, Additional Advocate General Raman Sharma, assisted by Advocate Saliqa Sheikh, and Advocate J. A. Hamal appeared. The petitioners challenged the chargesheet on the ground that the disputed mutation orders, bearing Nos. 3614 and 3615 dated March 30, 2010, had already been upheld by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kishtwar, in appellate proceedings. They contended that the disputed land formed part of Shamilat Deh and that the petitioners, being proprietary landholders of the village, possessed legitimate rights over their respective shares. They further argued that there was no evidence of bribery, criminal conspiracy or misuse of official position in securing the mutations. The respondents opposed the plea and referred to subsequent proceedings concerning the disputed revenue entries. They argued that the validity of the mutations remained contested and that the entries had allegedly been manipulated to obtain undue benefits. After examining the material on record, Justice Dhar observed that merely because a mutation order is disputed or considered erroneous, it does not necessarily follow that the revenue officer concerned has committed an offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act. The Court noted that revenue orders are subject to scrutiny by competent appellate and revisional authorities and that an incorrect order, by itself, cannot be treated as evidence of criminal misconduct. Significantly, the Court found that the material collected during the investigation did not disclose allegations of acceptance of illegal gratification or other pecuniary advantage by the revenue officials from the petitioners. It also found no material establishing a prior meeting of minds between the revenue officials and the beneficiaries for securing the mutations through abuse of official position. The High Court further observed that if the reasoning adopted by the investigating agency were accepted, even the Additional Deputy Commissioner, who had upheld the disputed mutation orders, could be treated as a co-conspirator. Justice Dhar described such a proposition as legally untenable. The Court also examined the prosecution's allegation that certain petitioners were shown in revenue records as possessing the land since 1971 despite having been born after that year. It observed that the revenue entries could reasonably refer to possession by the petitioners and their predecessors, and that this circumstance alone did not establish criminal wrongdoing. The Court held that the foundation of the prosecution case rested primarily on the attestation of the disputed mutations and that no independent material had been brought on record to establish the criminal intent necessary for prosecution. Concluding that the lodging of the FIR and filing of the chargesheet against the petitioners constituted an abuse of the process of law, the High Court allowed the petition and quashed the impugned FIR and consequential chargesheet insofar as they related to the petitioners. The judgment reinforces the principle that disputes concerning revenue mutations and land ownership cannot automatically be converted into criminal prosecutions in the absence of material disclosing the essential ingredients of a criminal offence. (JNF) |