news details |
|
|
| BSF school staff can't claim pay parity through writ: HC | | HC dismisses two petitions seeking Central Pay Commission benefits; employees free to pursue other legal remedies | | Early Times Report JAMMU, Nov 21: In a significant judgment concerning the service rights of teaching and non-teaching employees of BSF Senior Secondary School, Paloura, Jammu, the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has held that employees of the institution cannot enforce claims for pay parity with Central Government and Kendriya Vidyalaya staff through writ proceedings arising from contractual service disputes. Justice Sanjay Dhar dismissed two writ petitions filed by Soni Ram Dhaka and Chet Narayan Upadhyay and others, holding that the petitions were not maintainable under the writ jurisdiction of the High Court. The judgment, pronounced on November 19, 2026, concerns a legal dispute pending since 2014 and 2015 over revised salary scales, service benefits and implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth and Sixth Central Pay Commissions. The first petition, filed by Soni Ram Dhaka in 2014, sought directions to the authorities to adopt service rules in conformity with the applicable education laws and the affiliation bye-laws of the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE). The petitioner also sought promotion to the senior scale and selection scale along with consequential financial benefits. The second petition, instituted in 2015 by 42 teaching and non-teaching employees of BSF Senior Secondary School, Paloura, demanded implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth and Sixth Central Pay Commissions and payment of salaries and allowances at par with their counterparts employed in Central Government schools and Kendriya Vidyalayas. The petitioners also sought arrears of salary, other service benefits and protection against alleged vindictive action, including indiscriminate transfers. During the proceedings, Senior Advocate Sunil Sethi, assisted by Advocate Ravi Abrol, represented Soni Ram Dhaka, while Advocate Jasbir Singh Jasrotia appeared for the petitioners in the connected matter. For the respondents, Advocate Sumant Sudan appeared vice Deputy Solicitor General of India Vishal Sharma, while Senior Advocate Ajay Sharma, assisted by Advocate Naveed Naik, represented the school authorities in the connected petition. The petitioners argued that the school had been established by the Border Security Force and was affiliated with CBSE. They maintained that the institution was being operated on the pattern of Kendriya Vidyalayas and was subject to the control and supervision of BSF authorities. They contended that the teaching and non-teaching employees were performing duties comparable to those discharged by their counterparts in Central Government educational institutions and were therefore entitled to similar pay scales and service benefits. However, the school authorities opposed the petitions, contending that the institution was administered by the BSF Education Fund Society and did not receive financial assistance or grants from the Central or State Government. The respondents submitted that the institution was funded through voluntary contributions from BSF personnel and fees collected from students. They further argued that the school was being run as a welfare measure and could not bear the additional financial burden of granting full pay parity with Central Government employees. After examining the rival submissions, Justice Dhar referred to the Supreme Court judgment in St. Mary's Education Society, which addressed the maintainability of writ petitions arising from service disputes involving educational institutions. The High Court observed that although imparting education constitutes a public function, disputes relating to the contractual service conditions of teachers and non-teaching employees do not automatically acquire the character of public-law disputes. The Court noted that CBSE affiliation and its accompanying bye-laws do not, by themselves, create an enforceable right against the management through writ proceedings in such service matters. Justice Dhar further referred to judgments of the Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan High Courts concerning service disputes involving BSF educational institutions, where a similar view regarding maintainability had been taken. The Court held that employees alleging violations of service conditions or affiliation bye-laws could approach CBSE or pursue other remedies available under law, rather than necessarily invoking the writ jurisdiction of the High Court. Rejecting the maintainability of both petitions, Justice Dhar dismissed them without deciding the substantive entitlement of the employees to the claimed pay scales and benefits. However, the Court expressly left it opens to the petitioners to seek appropriate legal remedies. (JNF) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|