news details |
|
|
| Rape chargesheet cannot be quashed on victim's retraction: HC | | | Early Times Report JAMMU, Nov 21: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has ruled that a chargesheet in a rape case cannot be quashed merely because the complainant subsequently retracts her allegations through an affidavit, particularly when her statement has been recorded during investigation. The Court further held that a negative medical report alone cannot justify quashing criminal proceedings. Justice Rajnesh Oswal made these observations while dismissing a petition filed by Mohd. Zafer seeking quashing of Chargesheet No. 18/2012, arising out of FIR No. 93/2009 registered at Police Station Kandi, Rajouri, for an offence under Section 376 of the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC). The case originated from a complaint lodged in October 2009, alleging that the petitioner had sexually assaulted the complainant when she had gone to cut grass on her land. Following directions from the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Rajouri, police registered an FIR and initiated investigation. The petitioner contended that the allegations arose from a long-standing land dispute between the parties and that the complainant had subsequently executed an affidavit admitting that the complaint was false. He further submitted that the police had initially closed the investigation as "Not Proved" after considering the complainant's affidavit and medical report. According to him, the closure report had been accepted by the competent court, and reopening the investigation was legally impermissible. The petitioner also claimed that a compromise had been reached between the families through the intervention of village elders and that he had subsequently married the complainant in accordance with Shariat law. However, the police reopened the investigation following directions issued by the District Police Office, Rajouri, on March 10, 2011. During further investigation, the complainant's statement was recorded under Section 164-A Cr.P.C., and a chargesheet was subsequently filed against the petitioner. Advocate Ch. Mohd. Shabir, appearing for the petitioner, argued that the chargesheet deserved to be quashed in view of the complainant's affidavit, the negative medical evidence and the earlier closure of the investigation. He also relied upon the Supreme Court judgment in Pramod Kumar and Others versus State of Uttar Pradesh and Others. Opposing the plea, Advocate Tejasvini Anand, appearing for the official respondents in place of Government Advocate Bhanu Jasrotia, submitted that although a closure report had initially been prepared, the investigation was reopened on the directions of the supervisory officer. Advocate Waheed Choudhary, representing the complainant, argued that the compromise and subsequent marriage were allegedly used by the petitioner to frustrate the investigation and evade criminal proceedings. He further submitted that the petitioner had subsequently divorced the complainant. After examining the record, Justice Oswal observed that the petitioner had failed to produce documentary evidence establishing that the closure report had actually been submitted before and accepted by the competent court. The Court noted that the investigating officer had initially closed the case on the basis of the complainant's affidavit and negative medical report, but the higher police authorities had directed continuation of the investigation instead of accepting the closure. Distinguishing the Supreme Court judgment cited by the petitioner, the High Court observed that the ruling concerned further investigation after submission of a final report before a court, whereas the present case involved different circumstances. The Court held that once the complainant's statement under Section 164-A Cr.P.C. had been recorded, the chargesheet could not be quashed merely on the basis of an affidavit submitted by her during the investigation. Referring to the Supreme Court judgment in Deepak Kumar versus State of Chhattisgarh, 2025 INSC 929, the High Court further observed that a chargesheet cannot be quashed solely because the medical report does not support the prosecution case. Finding the petition devoid of merit, Justice Oswal dismissed the plea and vacated any interim directions operating in the matter. The ruling allows the criminal proceedings arising out of the 2009 FIR to continue in accordance with law. (JNF) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|