x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Teardown entire terrorist, separatist ecosystem: LG Sinha directs officials | Kishtwar SPO killings: FIR names unknown terrorists | Ladakh all set for Panchayat, Municipal elections today | Chief Justice visits District Court Complex Budgam | J&K Govt approves Rs 9.8 crore for street food hubs at Tangmarg, Lakhanpur: CM Omar | Probe non-listing of ED’s plea in bail matter for nearly 3-years: Apex Court | Bhupender Singh takes over as Inspector General BSF of Kashmir Frontier | Centre notifies revised disability assessment norms for 8 categories | Srinagar comes out of sub-zero | Fireman injured in firefighting operation | Tourism Department holds stakeholders meeting to plan Patnitop Carnival 2026 | Students of GGHS Pul Doda explore emerging technologies at ATL Lab | NMC proposes change in foreign medical graduate licensing rule | Prisons must become centres of human transformation | World Children’s Day: Its Importance and Need | Decisive Action | CPCO Amit Sharma leads Directorate's capacity-building push for Census 2027 Phase II; four-day Master Trainers' programme concludes in Jammu | Div Com felicitates artists at creative art camp on 'Humanity' at Vridh Ashram | Cheating has become norm, says PDP's Iltija demands probe into JKSSB exams | Power shut down by KPDCL | HC quashes ACB chargesheet in 60-kanal land mutation case | NC reiterates commitment to inclusive development of Jammu province: Nasir | Prime Minister Narendra Modi chairs plenary session of 'SAMAVESHI NITI SANKALP 2026' | JKSSB reaffirms integrity of Accounts Assistant Examination; appreciates swift action by J&K police | Jammu police execute PIT NDPS detention warrant against drug peddler in Akhnoor | Awantipora police takes action against illegal mining; seven tracks/ramps destroyed at Bujbagh | Rajouri police take strict action against overloading; three mini buses seized | LG approves honorary ranks for retiring non-gazetted police personnel in Ladakh | Hundreds bid tearful farewell to DSP Manoj Kumar Aryan in Kishtwar | Combined official visit of district chairman Dr Jasmin Kaur Gill - a grand success | KVK Reasi concludes five-day training programme on natural farming | DOMA confederation organizes 14th Education Camp | Examination for admission to class VI to be held in Bandipora District | Indian Army concluded welding skill development course for youth at Banihal | Blood donation awareness programme and blood donation camp organised at GDC Nowshera | "Asmita" programme on Dogri organised by Sahitya Akademi New Delhi" | DGR organises exservicemen job fair at Gurugram | SKUAST-Jammu organizes one-day training programme | Doda police organise medical check-up and drug abuse awareness camp at GGHS, Bun Doda | Back Issues  
 
news details
Promotion once granted can’t be snatched away without hearing employee: CAT
8/20/2026 9:56:54 PM
Early Times Report

Jammu, Aug 20: The Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Srinagar Bench, has quashed a 2012 order cancelling the promotion of a J&K Police employee, holding that once a promotion order has been issued, it cannot be withdrawn without first affording the employee an opportunity of hearing.
Judicial Member M.S. Latif, while deciding T.A. No. 3958/2021, arising out of SWP No. 18/2012, set aside the March 19, 2012 order cancelling the promotion of Mohammad Yaqoob, observing that the action violated the principles of natural justice and could not withstand the test of law.
The litigation had originally been instituted before the High Court of J&K in 2012. Yaqoob had sought quashing of Order No. 134 of 2012 dated March 19, 2012, besides consequential service benefits arising from an earlier promotion order issued in his favour.
According to the record, Yaqoob was serving in the Police Telecom wing and had earlier undergone a special driving and maintenance course. In 2011, he was nominated for an 18-week pre-promotion course for drivers at PTTI Vijaypur. After being relieved for the course, he underwent around 15 weeks of training when the authorities issued a communication stating that, being initially appointed as a constable, he could not be deputed for the course meant for driver constables. His pre-promotion training was consequently cancelled.
The High Court, however, intervened on January 11, 2012 and stayed the operation of the relevant wireless message as well as the order issued by the Principal, PTTI Vijaypur. Yaqoob was also permitted to appear in the pre-promotion course examination.
The Tribunal recorded that the interim order of the High Court had neither been challenged nor subsequently modified or reversed by any higher court.
Thereafter, Yaqoob was formally promoted through ZPHO Order No. 117/2012 dated March 15, 2012, but within four days the authorities issued Order No. 134/2012 dated March 19, cancelling his promotion.
Appearing for Yaqoob, Senior Counsel Syed Manzoor Ahmad argued that an employee whose promotion had already been ordered could not be deprived of it without notice and an opportunity to explain his position.
The Tribunal also referred to precedents cited before it to the effect that even where a promotion order results from a mistake, it cannot be cancelled without hearing the affected employee.
DAG Rais ud din Ganaie, appearing for the respondents, argued that Yaqoob had been erroneously deputed for the training and that once the error was detected, the competent authority had no option but to cancel the promotion and revert him.
The CAT, however, observed that even assuming the authorities had discovered an error, they were still bound to comply with the principles of natural justice before passing an adverse order.
The Tribunal said the authorities were required to issue a show-cause notice and provide the employee a reasonable opportunity to place his case before the competent authority. The record, however, did not show that any such exercise had been undertaken.
Significantly, CAT noted that the cancellation order itself gave no reason as to why the promotion already granted to Yaqoob was being withdrawn. It also did not indicate that any opportunity of hearing had been afforded to him, while the Government's reply similarly failed to substantiate that such an opportunity had ever been given.
Holding that the March 19, 2012 order had been passed in violation of law and the rules of natural justice, the Tribunal quashed and set aside the promotion cancellation order.
Taking note of the prolonged pendency of the dispute, the High Court's interim protection and the fact that Yaqoob had continued and qualified the required training, CAT directed him to submit a detailed representation before the competent authority for settlement of the period between the date of his promotion, its cancellation and the present judgment.
The competent authority has been directed to pass an appropriate order in accordance with law while also taking into consideration the period during which Yaqoob remained engaged in litigation before the courts.
The Tribunal's directions also disposed of connected O.A. No. 1059/2022, along with the connected applications. (JNF)
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU