Early Times Report JAMMU, Nov 17: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has set aside the conviction of three persons in a two-decade-old case involving an alleged assault on forest officials, holding that material contradictions, non-examination of crucial witnesses and serious prosecution lapses rendered the conviction unsustainable. Justice Shahzad Azeem allowed the appeal filed by Mohammad Latief Khan and two others, setting aside the judgment of conviction dated November 15, 2017, and sentencing order dated November 22, 2017, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Sopore. The case originated from an incident on June 20, 2006, when Forest Guard Ghulam Qadir Lone and his helper Harvinder Singh were allegedly attacked while patrolling forest compartment No. 21 in Rafiabad. According to the prosecution, the forest officials noticed certain persons cutting a kail tree. When they objected, the accused allegedly assaulted them, causing grievous injuries to the Forest Guard and simple injuries to his helper. An FIR was subsequently registered at Police Station Panzalla under various provisions of the Ranbir Penal Code and the Jammu and Kashmir Forest Act. The trial court convicted the first appellant under Section 325 RPC and Section 6 of the Forest Act, awarding 18 months' rigorous imprisonment and three months' simple imprisonment, respectively, along with fines. The remaining two appellants were sentenced to three months' simple imprisonment under the Forest Act. Challenging the conviction, the appellants contended that the prosecution had failed to examine crucial witnesses, including the Investigating Officer and another injured person present at the scene. Advocate Nisar Ahmad Bhat appeared for the appellants, while Government Advocate Jahingeer Ahmad Dar represented the prosecution. After examining the evidence, the High Court observed that the prosecution had examined only two of its five listed witnesses and that the testimony of the principal witness suffered from material contradictions and improvements. The court noted that the written complaint had not been properly proved and exhibited, while several questions concerning the alleged recovery of timber and an axe remained unanswered. The High Court further observed that the non-examination of the Investigating Officer assumed considerable significance because several discrepancies in the prosecution case required clarification. Significantly, the court found that the trial court had erroneously relied upon the accused's failure to offer a plausible explanation under Section 342 CrPC. The High Court held that the burden of establishing guilt beyond reasonable doubt rests entirely upon the prosecution and cannot be shifted to the accused. It further observed that medical evidence confirming injuries could not, by itself, establish the identity of the assailants or the manner in which the alleged assault had occurred. Holding that the prosecution had failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, the High Court set aside the conviction and sentence and acquitted all three appellants of the charges under Section 325 RPC and Section 6 of the Jammu and Kashmir Forest Act. The court also discharged the appellants from their bail bonds. (JNF) |