Early Times Report
Jammu, Nov 17: The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has held that a certificate merely showing an accused to be on official duty cannot automatically establish his absence from the scene of an alleged offence or justify quashing criminal proceedings. Justice Shahzad Azeem made the observation while disposing of a petition filed by Tariq Ahmad Sheikh seeking quashing of FIR No. 105/2025 registered at Police Station Hajin, Bandipora, and the consequential charge-sheet pending before the Judicial Magistrate, Sumbal. The FIR concerns alleged offences under Sections 329(3), 115(2), 74 and 351(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The petitioner contended that the alleged occurrence took place on November 29, 2025, when he was serving as Security Officer attached to the Special Secretary to Government, Department of Floriculture, Gardens and Parks. To support his claim, the petitioner relied upon official certificates dated December 11, 2025, and February 4, 2026, certifying his duty during the relevant period. Advocates Sheikh Mushtaq and Uzair appeared for the petitioner, while Government Advocate Jahangir Ahmad Dar represented the Union Territory. After examining the submissions, the High Court observed that the plea of alibi is essentially a defence based on facts and requires convincing evidence to establish that the accused could not have been present at the place of occurrence. The court noted that the certificates produced by the petitioner merely recorded his official duty status but did not specify the place of deployment, duty hours or whether his assignment was continuous. Without such particulars, the certificates could not conclusively establish that the petitioner was physically incapable of being present at the scene of the alleged incident. The High Court also distinguished the Supreme Court judgment in Rahul v. State of Uttar Pradesh, observing that the official duty certificate in that case established a specific assignment at a geographically distant location. The court held that a general duty certificate, without supporting particulars, does not satisfy the stringent requirements for quashing criminal proceedings on the ground of alibi. Declining to interfere with the FIR and charge-sheet at this stage, the High Court disposed of the petition while granting liberty to the petitioner to raise and establish his defence before the trial court at the appropriate stage, including during consideration of charge or discharge. (JNF) |