Early Times Report
Jammu, Nov 17: In a significant judgment arising from an alleged manipulation of an age certificate, the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has refused to quash cheating, conspiracy and corruption proceedings against two doctors accused of facilitating government employment benefits through an incorrect age assessment. Justice Sanjay Parihar partly allowed a petition filed by Dr. Gulzar Ahmad Bhat and Dr. Abdul Lateef Salik, both former members of a Medical Board in Srinagar, while holding that the allegations disclosed sufficient prima facie material to warrant further proceedings under the relevant provisions of law. The case relates to an age certificate issued on December 16, 1999, in favour of Ghulam Hassan Bhat, who allegedly used it to secure regularisation and permanent employment in the Public Health Engineering Department. According to the prosecution, the Medical Board assessed his age as 32 years in December 1999, placing his approximate year of birth in 1967. However, the investigation revealed that his biological son, Mohammad Shafi Bhat, had a recorded date of birth of February 25, 1966. The prosecution alleged that the assessment effectively made the father younger than his own son, raising serious questions about the genuineness of the age determination. It further alleged that the doctors, acting in conspiracy with the beneficiary, deliberately manipulated the assessment to facilitate employment-related benefits, thereby causing wrongful loss to the government exchequer. Advocate Salih Pirzada, assisted by Advocate Syed Ainain Qadri, represented the petitioners, while Senior Additional Advocate General Mohsin Qadri, assisted by Maha Majeed, appeared for Crime Branch Kashmir. The petitioners challenged the jurisdiction of the Crime Branch to investigate offences under the Jammu and Kashmir Prevention of Corruption Act, contending that such powers belonged exclusively to the Vigilance Organisation, now the Anti-Corruption Bureau. Rejecting this contention, the High Court held that the Crime Branch was not absolutely barred from investigating corruption-related offences, provided the statutory requirements governing the rank and authority of the investigating officer were satisfied. The court also examined whether the issuance of an allegedly incorrect age certificate constituted forgery. It observed that a document containing incorrect information does not automatically become a forged document when it has been issued by persons legally authorised to execute it. Accordingly, the High Court quashed the proceedings against the petitioners under Sections 467, 468 and 471 RPC, holding that the essential ingredients of forgery were not established by the allegations. However, the court found that the allegations of deliberate deception, conspiracy and abuse of official position disclosed sufficient prima facie grounds for further proceedings under Sections 420 and 120-B RPC, read with Section 5(2) of the Jammu and Kashmir Prevention of Corruption Act. The High Court permitted the investigating agency to proceed in accordance with law, subject to compliance with the statutory requirements concerning investigation and sanction for prosecution, wherever applicable. (JNF) |