Prof. Parshant Bakshi
“Artificial Intelligence may provide the answers, but Actual Intelligence determines which questions are worth asking, which answers deserve to be trusted, and how knowledge should be transformed into wisdom.” We are living in an era where machines are increasingly capable of performing tasks that were once considered exclusively human. From writing articles and analysing scientific data to diagnosing diseases, translating languages, designing buildings and predicting future trends, Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming almost every sphere of human activity. A machine can now prepare a research summary in seconds, generate an image from a simple instruction, analyse thousands of scientific observations and even participate in complex intellectual discussions. These developments have generated an important question: Will Artificial Intelligence eventually replace Actual Intelligence? The answer requires us to distinguish between the ability to process information and the ability to understand life, exercise judgement, demonstrate wisdom and take responsibility. Artificial Intelligence is essentially a product of human intelligence. It is developed, trained and improved through human knowledge, data, algorithms and technological innovation. Therefore, the question is not simply whether machines can become intelligent, but whether computational intelligence can completely substitute for the broader dimensions of human intelligence. 1. Understanding Artificial Intelligence and Actual Intelligence Artificial Intelligence refers to the capability of computer systems and machines to perform tasks that generally require cognitive abilities, such as learning, reasoning, pattern recognition, language processing and problem-solving. Actual Intelligence, in this context, refers to the comprehensive human capacity to think independently, understand situations, apply experience, exercise common sense, demonstrate emotional sensitivity, make ethical decisions and create meaning from knowledge. The distinction can be understood through a simple analogy: Artificial Intelligence can analyse thousands of agricultural experiments and identify the most productive treatment while the Actual Intelligence can understand the farmer’s economic condition, local soil characteristics, water availability, climatic uncertainties and social circumstances before recommending whether that treatment should be adopted. AI can process information, but human intelligence provides context, purpose and responsibility. 2. Can Artificial Intelligence Replace Actual Intelligence? Artificial Intelligence can replace or automate several tasks, particularly those involving repetitive activities, large-scale data processing, pattern recognition and standardised decision-making. However, replacing individual tasks is not the same as replacing human intelligence itself. Consider the following examples: A. In Education AI can prepare lectures, generate question papers, explain difficult concepts and evaluate certain types of assignments. However, a good teacher does much more than transfer information. A teacher recognises the potential of students, understands their difficulties, inspires confidence, develops character and provides motivation during challenging situations. A machine may explain a subject, but a teacher can transform a student’s attitude towards learning and life. B. In Medicine AI can analyse medical images, identify patterns in diagnostic reports and assist doctors in assessing disease risks. Nevertheless, a doctor must interpret these findings in the context of the patient’s history, circumstances, preferences and overall well-being. A diagnosis is not merely a technical report; it involves empathy, communication, ethical judgement and accountability. C. In Agriculture and Horticulture AI can analyse satellite images, weather forecasts, soil data, pest incidence and crop performance. It can help identify nutrient deficiencies, predict disease outbreaks and recommend irrigation schedules. However, an experienced horticultural scientist or extension professional understands that agricultural decisions must also consider farmers purchasing power, local microclimates, market fluctuations, traditional practices, labour availability and field realities. For example, an AI system may recommend a particular fertiliser schedule for an orchard. An experienced fruit scientist may modify that recommendation after examining root health, soil moisture, tree age, previous nutrient applications and the farmer’s financial resources. Thus, AI provides analytical support, while actual intelligence ensures practical relevance. 3. The Unique Advantages of Actual Intelligence There are several dimensions of human intelligence that distinguish it from present-day AI systems. 1. Emotional Intelligence and Empathy Human beings understand emotions through personal experiences, relationships and social interactions. Compassion, affection, trust, sympathy and emotional support are fundamental aspects of human relationships. A machine may recognise sadness in a person’s words, but recognising an emotion is not the same as personally experiencing it. 2. Common Sense and Situational Understanding Human beings often make decisions by combining knowledge with experience and an understanding of circumstances. A farmer may decide not to spray pesticides despite an AI-generated pest alert because rainfall is imminent, the pest population is below the economic threshold or beneficial insects are active in the orchard. Such decisions require contextual understanding rather than merely following a recommendation. 3. Creativity and Original Thinking AI can generate poems, designs, research ideas and scientific hypotheses by identifying patterns in existing information. Human beings, however, can question established assumptions, challenge conventional wisdom and create entirely new directions of thought. The ability to ask an unconventional question is often more important than the ability to generate a quick answer. 4. Ethical and Moral Judgement Not every technically possible action is socially desirable or ethically acceptable. Decisions involving privacy, fairness, environmental sustainability, human dignity and social justice require moral reasoning and accountability. AI can assist in evaluating alternatives, but responsibility for consequential decisions must remain with appropriately accountable human beings and institutions. 5. Intuition and Experience Experienced professionals often identify problems through subtle observations that may not be fully captured in available datasets. A fruit scientist may recognise an abnormal orchard condition through changes in leaf colour, shoot growth, fruit development or soil conditions even before a formal diagnostic report becomes available. Such observations reflect years of experience, practical exposure and accumulated knowledge. 4. Where Artificial Intelligence Has an Advantage A balanced discussion must also acknowledge the extraordinary strengths of AI. Artificial Intelligence Actual Intelligence Processes enormous datasets rapidly Understands broader human and social contexts Performs repetitive tasks consistently Adapts through lived experience Identifies complex data patterns Questions assumptions and interprets meaning Provides rapid information retrieval Evaluates relevance and credibility Works continuously without human fatigue Demonstrates empathy and emotional understanding Generates multiple possible solutions Exercises ethical and contextual judgement AI can process information at a scale and speed that no individual human can match. It can reduce routine workloads, improve analytical efficiency and make specialised knowledge more accessible. However, AI-generated information can also contain errors, outdated assumptions and fabricated references. Therefore, human verification remains essential. 5. The Real Advantage: When Actual Intelligence Uses Artificial Intelligence Perhaps the most important question is not whether AI will replace human intelligence, but how human intelligence can use AI to become more effective. The combination of the two creates a powerful partnership. Consider a few examples: Example 1: Scientific Research A researcher may take several months to review hundreds of scientific papers. AI can help screen literature, organise references, identify research gaps and analyse experimental data. But the researcher must decide whether the research question is scientifically meaningful, whether the methodology is appropriate, how the findings should be interpreted and what contribution they make to society. AI accelerates research; the scientist provides scientific direction and integrity. Example 2: Fruit Crop Improvement AI can analyse genetic information, weather patterns, yield records and fruit quality parameters to identify promising genotypes. However, an experienced plant breeder must evaluate adaptability, consumer preference, disease resistance, nutritional value, sustainability and commercial feasibility before recommending a variety. Example 3: Climate-Smart Agriculture AI-based forecasting can help predict temperature fluctuations, rainfall patterns and potential crop stress. Human intelligence can translate these predictions into practical strategies for farmers, considering local resources, indigenous knowledge and livelihood security. Example 4: Institutional Leadership AI can prepare reports, analyse institutional performance, organise data and identify administrative gaps. But leadership involves motivating colleagues, resolving conflicts, building trust, encouraging innovation and making decisions that balance institutional objectives with human considerations. An institution may be managed through data, but it can only be developed through vision, commitment and responsible leadership. 6. The Danger of Depending Excessively on Artificial Intelligence While AI offers tremendous opportunities, excessive dependence can create intellectual challenges. • If students use AI to write every assignment without understanding the subject, their analytical and creative abilities may gradually weaken. • If researchers accept AI-generated references and conclusions without verification, scientific integrity may be compromised. • If administrators depend entirely on automated recommendations, they may overlook local realities and human considerations. • If society begins to treat every AI-generated answer as unquestionably correct, independent thinking may decline. The greatest danger is not necessarily that AI will become more intelligent than human beings; it is that human beings may stop exercising their own intelligence because AI makes thinking appear unnecessary. Technology should reduce intellectual drudgery, not intellectual curiosity. 7. The Future Belongs to Intelligent Human Beings, Not Merely Intelligent Machines The future will increasingly reward individuals who can combine subject expertise, critical thinking, creativity, ethical judgement and technological competence. • Students must learn how to use AI, but they must also learn how to question it. • Scientists must embrace AI-based research tools, but they must retain scientific curiosity and independent verification. • Teachers must use AI to improve educational delivery, but they must continue nurturing values, character and critical thinking. • Farmers and agricultural professionals must adopt digital technologies, but practical field knowledge and local wisdom must remain central to agricultural development. The objective should be to develop AI-literate and intellectually independent individuals rather than individuals who become dependent on AI. 8. A New Concept: Human Intelligence + Artificial Intelligence = Augmented Intelligence Instead of treating Artificial Intelligence and Actual Intelligence as competitors, we should recognise their complementary strengths. Artificial Intelligence provides speed, computational power, data processing and analytical support. Actual Intelligence provides vision, experience, intuition, creativity, empathy, ethics and accountability. When these capabilities work together, they create what is increasingly described as Augmented Intelligence. It is not about allowing machines to think on behalf of human beings; it is about enabling human beings to think, create and perform better with the assistance of machines. Conclusion: Machines May Become Smarter, but Wisdom Must Remain Human Artificial Intelligence is undoubtedly one of the most transformative innovations of our time. It will reshape education, research, agriculture, healthcare, governance, industry and almost every profession. However, the advancement of technology should never be confused with the replacement of human wisdom. A machine can calculate the shortest route, but a human being decides the destination. A machine can analyse the nutritional composition of a fruit, but a scientist understands its importance for human nutrition and farming livelihoods. A machine can generate thousands of ideas, but human intelligence determines which ideas deserve to be pursued. Ultimately, the real competition is not between Artificial Intelligence and Actual Intelligence. It is between human beings who use technology wisely and those who surrender their ability to think independently. We must remember that Artificial Intelligence is a creation of human intelligence. Its greatest purpose should be to strengthen human potential, not diminish it. The future does not belong to Artificial Intelligence alone, nor to human intelligence working in isolation. It belongs to those who can combine the power of machines with the wisdom of human beings. Artificial Intelligence can provide information, but Actual Intelligence creates understanding. Artificial Intelligence can generate possibilities, but Actual Intelligence gives them purpose. And while machines may assist us in finding answers, the responsibility to ask meaningful questions, make wise decisions and serve humanity must always remain ours. |