x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   All eyes on today’s crucial meeting of alliance MLAs | 48 JKAS officers transferred on LG’s direction | Karra, Mir to skip Omar’s ‘emergency meeting’ | Kathua combing operation enters 12th day | Suspected terrorists spotted in Udhampur | Amit Shah to arrive in J&K for 3 day visit on Apr 6 | Govt enhances social pensions | ACB registers cases against public representatives | 2 imposters posing as police officers arrested | Cyber Police identify 200 social media handles propagating extremist content | India, Thailand support inclusive rules: PM Modi | CB books 7, including paramedical Institute owner, for duping innocents | EPFO eases claim process | No fee to be charged for updation of nominees PPF accounts: Sitharaman | LG Sinha reviews progress | MeT predicts light rains, gusty winds | Shortage of 22 lakh skilled drivers in India: Gadkari | Burglars loot 6 shops in Poonch | Sakeena Itoo conducts extensive tour of Shangus-Anantnag East Constituency | MLA Vikram Randhawa launches Rs 60 lakh development projects | LA Speaker inaugurates Royal Health, Wellness Centre at Srinagar | EPFO achieves major milestones in J&K, Ladakh | Citizen-Centric Governance | Tawi, Ravi Canals being recharged on April 7-2025 | IIIM Bonera leads Tulip Indigenization Effort | Felicitation ceremony held for second batch of Anti-Extremist Tactics Course | PM Modi shatters Waqf Board's arbitrary claims on Mahakumbh land, says CM Yogi | Omar-Led Govt implementing poll promises at unprecedented speed: Rattan Lal Gupta | Serving Nation is BJP's sole mission: Kavinder | Lieutenant Governor addresses Balaji Foundation's 'Bharat Shiksha Summit' | 8 more Kashmir Crafts carve their way to GI Glory | DB rejects bail of LeT supporter | No proposal received yet to appoint ad-hoc Judges in HCs: Govt | JKAACL hosts literary event honoring Padma Shri Narsingh Dev Jamwal | Desh Bhagat Radio celebrated Bollywood Day | SKPA Udhampur hosts training on communication, public interaction for J&K police | Volleyball tournament in memory of martyr PSI Deepak Sharma concludes | Vijay Kumar Magotra conferred with Doctorate in Mass Communication & Journalism | Absconder arrested by Bishnah police after 12 years on the run | Drug awareness program organized at Ghou Manhasa | Samba police foil two major bovine smuggling attempts, rescue 44 cattle | SKUAST-Jammu's Entomological Science Academy celebrates World Aquatic Animal Day | GDC Paloura organizes 60-hour training program | Carrom Competition organizes at GDC RS Pura | World Boxing Cup: Manish, Hitesh, Abhinash cruise into semifinals | GCOE Jammu organizes Awareness Rally | GGM Science College organizes Table Tennis matches | GDC Sidhra organizes IEC Campaign against drug abuse | Suryakumar is not going anywhere from Mumbai: MCA | Tennis star Coco Gauff is starting her own management firm | Exposure to difficult conditions helped evolution of my T20 batting: Sai Sudharsan | Hockey India Senior Men National Championship under new format begins on Apr 4 in Jhansi | Pretty embarrassed at dropping Salt, so was determined to score some runs: Buttler | Back Issues  
 
news details
Court acquits then Additional CS, others in jute mat scam
5/6/2022 11:31:04 PM

Early Times Report

JAMMU, May 6: After 23 years of investigation and trial, Special Judge anti-corruption Ritesh Kumar Dubey acquitted Ajit Kumar, then Additional Chief Secretary, Janak Singh Financial Advisor/Chief Accounts Officer, Ghulam Rasool Vakil alias Lassa Vakil in much publicized jute mat scam.
The case was registered on the basis of a preliminary enquiry wherein it was established prima facie that the SLPC members of Education Department headed by Kumar then Additional Chief Secretary (hereinafter referred as A-1) had placed a supply order for three lac meters of Jute Mats with M/s Commercial Corporation Limited Srinagar on exorbitant rates in the year 1997-98, and caused huge loss to the state exchequer by abuse of their official positions, in connivance with the supplier firm.
The SLPC comprised of Additional Chief Secretary as Chairman, Directors School Education Kashmir/Jammu and Director Industries or his representatives (not below the rank of Joint Director) as members, and FA/CAO Education department as member secretary.
By virtue of an addendum to earlier order, another member Additional Secretary to Government, Education Department, was also included in the SLPC vide order dated 8-10-1997, who was A. R. Mubarki.
The special judge anti-corruption observed that the prosecution has also failed in explaining why certain officers were picked and chosen for prosecution, and certain others left by believing them not guilty of any misconduct. If Kumar was guilty of misconduct in the SLPC, the other members were equally responsible for the collective decision in the meeting except A.K Mehta who made his endorsement of the minutes of meeting subject to the observations recorded by him.
The court also considered the fact of recovery of a diary reflecting payments to Government officers, and initials 'A' and 'A.K' with allegation of payments also to the persons with said initials. Again, the prosecution has not led any evidence in this regard. Noting that the diary is alleged to be of accused no. 3, the prosecution could have led circumstantial evidence in this regard also. The possible evidence could also include the statement of Nazir Ahmed Mattoo.
The court observed that the prosecution cannot be allowed to seek evidence to rebut the said and other pieces of evidence, by the accused, instead of first itself proving the same under law. The situation was that the prosecution had failed in proving that the accused did not conduct the enquiry as claimed by him, whereas the prosecution has failed to discharge the burden of proving the facts alleged by it in the present case, and not just failed in leading evidence against some fact pleaded by the accused. In view of the observation made herein before, the prosecution has allowed the missing links noted herein before, to enter its chain of circumstances thereby either weakening or breaking the same.
Also, if the accused herein were believed guilty by the prosecution, on the basis of purchase of jute mat in the present case the leaving of others involved also becomes missing link in the prosecution chain of circumstances. And the law is well settled that the prosecution must establish its case in such a manner that its chain of circumstances is not broken or weakened by any possible doubt, and that the same leads to one and only one hypothesis pointing to the guild of accused. The prosecution efforts fall short of achieving the same in this case.
With these observations Court is not convinced that the prosecution has been able to remove the element of doubt from its accusations against the accused as well as the charge framed by this court, beyond the shadows of all reasonable doubts by such strong evidence as could lead to one and only one hypothesis pointing to the guilt of the accused and acquitted the accused persons.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU